Which Penny Would You Prefer? 4

1909 would end the 50 years of the Indian Cent and introduce a new design to the world. It was decided to put Abraham Lincoln on the penny to honor the centennial anniversary of his birth.

Both pennies were minted in Philadelphia and San Francisco that year. In fact, before 1908, cents would only be minted at the Philadelphia mint. San Francisco had only minted silver and gold coins, but in 1908, an ‘S’ mint mark would appear on a cent for the first time.

So, which would prefer, a 1909-S Indian Cent or a 1909-S Lincoln Cent? Better yet, would you prefer a 1909-S Indian Cent or a 1909-S VDB Lincoln Cent? Let’s see…

1909-S Indian Cent

Although cents were starting to be minted in San Francisco, they would mint significantly less of them than Philadelphia. Only 309,000 Indian Cents would be minted in San Francisco, making the 1909-S the rarest Indian Cent. Even the popular 1877 Indian Cent had more minted at 852,500. Even though there less than half as many 1909-S cents as 1877, the 1877 cent is worth twice as much as the 1909-S in good condition and more than three times in uncirculated condition. Some believe this is because people held onto the 1909-S cents knowing that it was the last year of the series. Others believe there were significantly less 1877’s minted. In any case, the 1909-S Indian Cent is definitely under evaluated.

1909-S VDB Lincoln Cent

On August 2nd, the first Lincoln Cents were released to the public. At the bottom of the reverse of the coin was the designer Victor D. Brenner’s initials, VDB. During that day came opposition of the initials appearing on the coin. Some thought it was personal advertising for the designer. Back then, most coins only had the last initial of the designer and Charles Barber, whose last initial ‘B’ appeared on the current dimes, quarters and half dollars, wasn’t too happy to see just a ‘B’ on the penny. The mint stopped minting the cents with the initials and the remainder of the year would see no VDB on the reverse. Only 484,000 VDB Lincoln Cents were minted in San Francisco. Even though there were less 1909-S Indian Cents than 1909-S VDB Lincoln Cents, the Lincoln Cent would be more popular and more sought at, and valued higher than the Indian cent.

1909-S Lincoln Cent

With the 1909-S Lincoln Cent being minted the remaining third of the year, it would have a higher mintage than the Indian Cent and VDB Lincoln Cent combined, at 1,825,000. This would make it the least valuable of the three, but still not bad since it is worth $100 in good condition and $300 in uncirculated condition.

Moral of the Story

When looking at coins, rarity is not the only factor that makes a coin more valuable. Most people didn’t realize back then that there were less 1909-S Indian Cents than 1909-S VDB Lincoln Cent. The VDB Lincoln Cents were minted in less time. So, most people thought there were less of them and went for them over the Indian Cent. So, do your research when looking at rare coins. Of course, if you do get one of these cents, make sure it’s a legitimate San Francisco cent. Some counterfeiters will try to add a ‘S’ mint mark to a 1909 Philadelphia cent.

Good luck on your coin collection endeavors!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

4 thoughts on “Which Penny Would You Prefer?

  • Eric Chen

    Hello Kevin,

    Wow, very interesting article on coins! I’ve never been a huge fan of collecting coins myself, but I started recently because I thought I found a rare coin in my dresser. Turns out it was a nickel that was worth about a dollar haha!

    In all honestly, I would totally go for the indian head simply because I’ve never had or seen that version before.

    Thanks again for the education!

    Kind Regards,

    • Kevin Post author

      Indian Cents are a nice set. Only a few key dates and were made of copper and nickel until 1864 with people hoarding them during the Civil War. That made Congress change the composition to remove the nickel. I have a few of them. I think they had a nice design at a time when there were many Liberty Seated and Barber coins. Thanks for the comment Eric!

  • Jerry Burns

    Thanks for the great post. There is a lot of information that I have work through. I appreciate the great article and can tell that a lot of work and research went into putting this together.

    Very cool. Do you have any coins yourself? Do you have any coins worth any money?

    Great post.

    • Kevin Post author

      Thanks for the comment Jerry. I do have coins, some worth more than I expected. I’ve been collecting on and off for almost 40 years.