Is There a New US Dollar Coin in Our Future? 8

On September 14, 2016, Rep. Jim Himes of Connecticut introduced legislation for a dollar coin to honor American Innovation. This would replace the Presidential Dollars that ended in 2016. The plan, similar to the state quarters, would be to mint a coin from each state, US territory and the District of Columbia. The mint would produce 4 different designs each year for 14 years.  Interesting idea, but will collectors and the public go for it? For over 50 years, the United States Mint has tried to produce a dollar that would do well in circulation, but has had very little success.

Peace Dollar

The last Silver Dollar in the US was the 1935 Peace Dollar. There was an attempt in the 1960’s to bring back the dollar by minting 45,000,000 Peace Dollars, but it was too late. There was talk about removing silver from US coins and a fear that people would hoard these silver dollars instead of spending them. In the end, there were only 316,000 1964 Peace Dollars produced out of the Denver mint, and were supposedly all melted. There have been rumors that a few may have made it out of the mint, but none have been seen.

Eisenhower Dollar

In 1971, a new dollar was minted to commemorate President Dwight  D. Eisenhower, who passed away on March 28, 1969.  Clad circulating coins, composed of copper and nickel, would be minted at the Philadelphia and Denver mints and clad proof coins would be minted in San Francisco. For collectors, there would be uncirculated 40% silver dollars in blue envelopes and proof 40% silver dollars in brown boxes from San Francisco, known as blue and brown Ikes. The blue and brown Ikes were released from 1971 to 1974. With the Bicentennial of the United States occurring in 1976, the mint would produce special reverses on the Washington Quarter, Kennedy Half Dollar and Eisenhower Dollar starting in 1975. Instead of the years 1975 or 1976, the date on these coins would display 1776*1976. The Eisenhower Dollar only lasted 8 years, ending in 1978. Even though there were a lot of circulating Ikes minted, people were not using them. Many thought they were too big to spend. They definitely weighed down pockets and purses. As a result, the mint would start minting a smaller dollar.

Susan B. Anthony Dollar

By 1977, the US government was looking to produce a smaller dollar for circulation. The idea was to create a modern Liberty design. During the 1970’s, many woman were trying to get the Equal Rights Amendment passed which gave the idea to put an actual woman on the new dollar coin. The 20th century saw men, mostly presidents, on the obverse sides of US coins, but for the first time, a woman would be used. It was decided to use Susan B. Anthony who was a well known social reformer. The Susan B. Anthony Dollar was introduced to the public in 1979.  In the first year, over 750,000,000 would be minted between the Philadelphia, Denver and San Francisco mints. Unfortunately, the Susan B. Anthony Dollar, like the Eisenhower Dollar would not be popular to the public. It was smaller and lighter than the Eisenhower Dollar, but the size of this new dollar was close to the size of the Washington Quarter. So, most of the Susan B. Anthony Dollars were accidentally being used as quarters if people didn’t look at the coins closely. Because of this, there would be less than 100,000,000 minted in 1980, and by 1981, they would only show up in mint and proof sets. The US government ended up with a surplus of 520,000,000 dollars, and until they could get rid of them, no more dollar coins would be minted. After 1981, they would primarily be used in Post Office vending machines to buy stamps. Supposedly, the Susan B. Anthony Dollar would be used as tokens at the Baltimore Metro Subway. By 1997, there was talk about creating a new dollar, but with Susan B. Anthony dollars finally depleted and the new dollar not ready, 41,000,000 more Susan B. Anthony dollars would be minted in 1999, primarily for the stamp vending machines.

Sacagawea Dollars

In 1987, Canada would introduce an eleven sided, gold colored dollar. Like the Susan B. Anthony Dollar, the new Canadian dollar was similar to size as the quarter, but with the gold color, it was easier to distinguish. With the popularity of this Canadian dollar, the dollar bill would be eliminated by 1989.

By 1997, most of the US government’s Susan B. Anthony dollars had depleted and a new dollar was being considered that would be similar to the successful Canadian Dollar. The new US Dollar, would be gold colored and display Sacagawea, the Native American guide for Lewis and Clark between 1804 and 1806. The new dollars would start being released in 2000. Even with the new golden color, the Sacagawea Dollar would not prove to be popular with the public and many of the new dollars would end up in government vaults like the Susan B. Anthony dollar. With the unpopularity of the new Sacagawea Dollars, the new dollar would be taken out of circulation and only released in mint and proof sets within 2 years of release.

In a new attempt to get the Sacagawea Dollar back in circulation and with the popularity of the State Quarters, the US mint would produce what would be known as Native American Dollars starting in 2009. These dollars would continue to have Sacagawea on the obverse, but would have a different design each year on the reverse memorializing Native Americans. This time, the government did it right by not producing as many circulating Native American Dollars like the early Susan B. Anthony and Sacagawea Dollars to see if the public would use them. They would only produce between 70,000,000 and 80,000,000 each year from 2009 and 2011. With lack of use, the dollar would once again leave circulation.

Presidential Dollars

The 2000s saw the success of the State Quarters and with them coming to the end, the US government wanted to produce a coin that they thought would be as successful. In 2007, the US Mint would release new gold color dollar coins with the faces of the first four US Presidents. They would release four coins each year for the next 10 years, except for 2016 which only had three released. The first 38 Presidents from George Washington to Gerald Ford would be displayed. The last President to be displayed would be Ronald Reagan for a total of 39 different coins. The remaining Presidents who were still living as of 2016, Jimmy Carter, George H.W. Bush, Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, and Barack Obama would not be included.

The new Presidential Dollars started off well, but by 2011, the popularity wore off. From 2012 to 2016, the Presidential Dollars would not be released in circulation.

If the American Innovations Dollar Get Approved, Will it Be Successful?

As of January, 2018, the new Dollar has not been approved, but what if it does? Since silver has been removed from circulating coins, the dollar has not seen much popularity. I’ve got to ask, why? Canada’s dollar coin was successful enough to eliminate the dollar bill 30 years ago, and the US can’t even find any success with their versions of the gold color coins. Do you think an American Innovations Dollar could be successful, or should the government consider a new design for the American dollar coin?

Related Articles

The Peace Dollar – The 20th Century’s Silver Dollar
Do You Like Ike?
Collecting Sacagawea Dollars
Last of the Presidents

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

8 thoughts on “Is There a New US Dollar Coin in Our Future?

  • Ann & Alex

    I thought I heard that they were going to try another coin dollar. They have to stop making is so close in size to the quarter.

    The dollar coin size is the problem I believe because it’s so close to the quarter size. Even though they are changing the color to gold it still might be hard to tell the difference for some people.

    I look forward to seeing the new dollar if it should get approved.

    Thanks for the great information

    • Kevin Post author

      Thanks for the comment Ann! I can understand the Susan B. Anthony dollar couldn’t work because of its size and color, but I thought the gold color dollars would work like they did in Canada. Nothing against doing American Innovation Dollars, but I don’t think it would be enough for people to spend them. I thought people would use the Presidential Dollars or the Sacagawea Dollars, but neither have been too successful. I think the government and the mint should ask the people what they would like to see.

  • Advent Voice

    Coin Collections!
    I love your work and the time you take to keep people informed on the necessity of keeping tabs on investment and the worth of coins.
    What is your take on Bitcoin?
    I have written a few articles on it because as an artist I love to keep tabs on where my money is going and coming from. Art is so expensive, especially when it has the purpose I have proposed for my art.
    I would love to invest with you because you seem honest and I am sure that is why you are able to attract to so many customers.
    When it comes to money and where to invest we have to be so true to those we speak with.
    Thank you for showing the world the importance of money and where it can take us.

    • Kevin Post author

      Thanks for the comment! I’m just now starting to learn a little about cryptocurrency. I don’t think now would be a good time to invest in bitcoin as it just hit its high and the fear of regulation seems to be bringing it down. I had heard about it the past few years, but never looked into it. It looks like there are others out there. I was reading about one this past week call r2b. I’ve been thinking about doing an article about cryptocurrency, but I have more to learn, like mining. 

      I appreciate you calling me honest. I hope all people reading my posts think that too. I want people to enjoy coin collecting like my friends and I have over the years. Not only do I want to educate others, but I also want to learn from others. I don’t know everything about coins which was part of the reason I decided to do a blog about them.

      I wish you well on your art and investing. Come back often and let me know how you’re doing. I’m 3 away from my 100th post and I plan on talking about Morgan Dollars which are popular for collecting and investing.

  • Alex

    Great content on your website & very interesting reads! I’d recommend breaking your paragraphs a little bit more but otherwise, I really enjoyed reading your post especially since my dad likes to collect coins & I’ve always loved reading about them. Thanks for sharing all that info with all of us!

    • Kevin Post author

      Thanks for the comment Alex! That’s great that your dad collects coins. What does he collect? I’m glad you liked the article.

  • CLyde James

    The reason the coins don’t “catch on” is that the government continues to print dollar bills. In every single country on earth where low value paper denominations have been transitioned to coins, the introduction of the coin coincided with the complete cancellation of production of the bill. When we do that, we’ll have a circulating dollar coin. Not before. It’s not rocket science, but then the US Congress doesn’t even understand 2+2=4.

    • Kevin Post author

      Sadly, you’re right Clyde. I read recently that the US is one of three countries that don’t have a circulating dollar coin, or something similar. If Canada can have a successful dollar and two dollar coin, why can’t the United States. They even stopped minting the penny in 2012. Let’s hope that Congress will figure this out. Thanks for the comment Clyde!